JRE #1193 - Shane Dorian

5-Nov-18

Joe Rogan Podcast #1193 – Shane Dorian: Topics and Themes

This Joe Rogan podcast features Shane Dorian, a big-wave surfer and bowhunter, offering insights into his unique lifestyle and the pressures of professional surfing. The conversation touches on topics ranging from the competitive nature of sports, the mental game, the challenges of making a living from surfing, the ethical implications of hunting, and the impact of invasive species. The podcast also delves into fascinating cultural and technological advancements, particularly in Japan and the realm of renewable energy.

Major Topics and Themes:

Here are some of the major topics discussed in the podcast, with a 4-point summary of each:

1. The Competitive Spirit and its Effects:

Dorian discusses the intense competitive nature of professional surfing, revealing how he used to visualize harmful things happening to his opponents during heats.
He acknowledges the inherent competitiveness in human nature, especially among men, which often manifests in various pursuits.
Dorian contrasts his former hyper-competitive mindset with his current relaxed approach to surfing, highlighting a shift in perspective after prioritizing personal enjoyment over competition.
He draws parallels to the fight world, emphasizing the emotional and psychological impact of competition, especially in martial arts.

2. The Mental Game in Surfing and Hunting:

Dorian emphasizes the importance of a calm and focused mindset for peak performance in both surfing and hunting.
He explains how emotional stress can hinder performance, especially in high-pressure situations like hunting big game or facing a formidable opponent in a fight.
He describes the mental state required for surfing, highlighting the need for flow and adaptability, unlike the more structured nature of competitive sports.
He relates the mental game in hunting to the challenge of overcoming target panic, a phenomenon that can impede a hunter’s ability to make a clean shot.

3. The Unique Lifestyle of a Big-Wave Surfer:

Dorian explains the challenges of making a living from surfing, especially as a free surfer who doesn’t compete professionally.
He discusses how he relies on sponsorships and brand endorsements, highlighting the unique economic landscape of professional surfing.
He reflects on the difficulty of explaining his career to those unfamiliar with surfing, emphasizing the disconnect between his lifestyle and conventional work experiences.
He expresses his appreciation for surfing beyond competition, emphasizing the joy of sharing it with his family and friends, and the serenity it provides.

4. The Ethical Considerations of Hunting:

Dorian defends his hunting practices as a form of ethical and responsible wildlife management.
He argues that hunting is necessary to control invasive species populations, especially on islands where natural predators are absent.
He discusses the importance of sustainable hunting practices and the use of harvested meat, highlighting the role of hunters in ensuring healthy wildlife populations.
He criticizes the knee-jerk reactions of animal rights activists who often condemn hunting without understanding the complex ecological considerations.

5. The Impact of Invasive Species:

Dorian discusses the devastating effects of invasive species, like Axis deer and goats, on native ecosystems.
He emphasizes the need for controlled management of these populations to protect the delicate balance of native wildlife and plant life.
He shares his experiences hunting Axis deer in Hawaii, highlighting their unusual speed and agility, and the unique challenges they pose for hunters.
He discusses the controversy surrounding a woman who was criticized for hunting wild sheep in Europe, emphasizing the importance of understanding the role of hunting in conservation efforts.

6. The Technological Advancements in Japan and Renewable Energy:

Dorian marvels at the technological advancements in Japan, especially the efficient and highly developed nature of its cities.
He contrasts the traditional aspects of Japanese culture with its modern technological marvels, highlighting the rapid progress and innovation in the country.
He discusses the advancements in renewable energy technologies, particularly solar panels, and his own experience installing solar panels on his home in Hawaii.
He addresses the challenges of adopting solar power, including bureaucratic hurdles and the reluctance of some power companies.

7. The Allure and Danger of Belief Systems:

Dorian discusses the impact of belief systems on individuals, referencing the story of Terence McKenna, a prominent psychedelic advocate.
He shares his perspective on the Big Island of Hawaii, noting the unique energy and spiritual draw of the place, attracting those seeking alternative lifestyles.
He touches on the dangers of unquestioning commitment to rigid belief systems, hinting at the potential for exploitation and manipulation.
He contrasts the intense focus and dedication required for certain pursuits, like acting or surfing, with the potential for obsession and a loss of balance.

8. The Influence of Social Media and Public Perception:

Dorian criticizes the tendency for people to use social media to vent anger and judgment, often without a full understanding of the situation.
He notes the hypocrisy of those who condemn hunting while simultaneously consuming meat, highlighting the disconnect between their actions and their beliefs.
He discusses the distorted perception of reality created by social media, where sensationalism and outrage often trump nuanced understanding.
He emphasizes the importance of critical thinking and seeking accurate information before forming judgments, especially on complex topics like conservation and wildlife management.

9. The Reality of Meat Consumption and the Disconnect from its Source:

Dorian challenges the widespread disconnect between meat consumption and the reality of animal death, suggesting that most people are insulated from the process.
He proposes a hypothetical scenario where individuals must directly participate in the killing of animals to earn the right to consume meat, highlighting the importance of understanding the source of their food.
He emphasizes the respect and appreciation for the animal that comes with actively participating in the hunting and processing of meat, fostering a deeper connection to the food source.
He argues that this disconnect is detrimental to our understanding of the food system and our relationship with nature.

10. The Culture of Celebrity and the Power Dynamics of Wealth:

Dorian discusses the cultural phenomenon of celebrity and the often distorted perception of wealthy individuals.
He critiques the tendency for wealthy individuals to believe they are above the rules, citing instances where they have attempted to restrict public access to beaches.
He highlights the hypocrisy of those who preach environmentalism while simultaneously engaging in unsustainable practices, like building large, energy-intensive homes.
He emphasizes the importance of respecting cultural norms and the environment, regardless of wealth or status.

11. The Importance of Personal Connection and Authentic Experiences:

Dorian highlights the value of authentic experiences, like hunting or surfing, which connect individuals to nature and their own capabilities.
He contrasts these experiences with the manufactured and often superficial nature of celebrity culture, emphasizing the importance of genuine connection and fulfillment.
He suggests that a lack of these authentic experiences can contribute to a sense of disconnect and dissatisfaction in modern society.
He encourages individuals to seek out experiences that foster personal growth and connection with the world around them.

12. The Importance of Understanding and Respecting Different Cultures:

Dorian shares his perspective on the cultural differences between Hawaii and mainland America, highlighting the unique values and pace of life in Hawaii.
He discusses the importance of respecting cultural norms and traditions, especially when visiting or moving to a new place.
He warns against the dangers of homogenization, where individuals attempt to impose their own cultural values on a different community.
He encourages a spirit of understanding and appreciation for the diversity of cultures and lifestyles across the world.

13. The Value of Personal Responsibility and Respect for the Environment:

Dorian emphasizes the responsibility of individuals to be informed about the environmental impacts of their actions.
He encourages a sense of stewardship for the natural world, advocating for responsible practices like sustainable hunting and wildlife management.
He cautions against the dangers of blind consumerism and the disconnect from the source of our food and materials.
He promotes a balanced approach to human interaction with nature, acknowledging the need for both utilization and preservation.

14. The Importance of Open Dialogue and Critical Thinking:

Dorian advocates for open and honest dialogue on complex and often controversial topics.
He encourages individuals to challenge their own biases and assumptions, and to be open to different perspectives.
He emphasizes the importance of critical thinking and fact-checking, especially in an age of misinformation and sensationalism.
He promotes a spirit of intellectual curiosity and a desire to understand the world around us more fully.

15. The Power of Connection and Shared Experiences:

Dorian highlights the importance of strong relationships and shared experiences, particularly within a community.
He emphasizes the value of hunting and surfing as activities that bring people together and foster a sense of camaraderie.
He discusses the role of shared values and experiences in building strong bonds and creating lasting memories.
He encourages individuals to seek out and cultivate connections with others who share their passions and interests.

Memorable Quotes:

“I think he’s too smart. Too smart to talk to regular people.” – Joe Rogan, commenting on Elon Musk’s intelligence and unconventional thinking.
“I’m not a fight nerd, but he was getting fucked up. But he was, I’m like, dude, the guy’s losing the fight. There’s 0 chance to win. Next you know he won.” – Joe Rogan, describing an unexpected turn of events in a fight.
“Surfing, I think surfing is, like, ideally suited for competition. I don’t see surfing as a sport whatsoever.” – Shane Dorian, expressing his view on surfing as an individual pursuit that transcends competition.
“Those moments don’t happen very often, man. No. They don’t. That that is what what a lot of people like yourself or myself are chasing. You’re always chasing these these above average moments, these high level moments, these moments where you just Everything’s elevated.” – Shane Dorian, reflecting on the pursuit of peak experiences in life.
“I love that about real guys. Like, I wouldn’t do it, but, like, Elon Musk and and Zuckerberg. It’s it’s cool. Those guys believe so much that they can actually make a difference, that they’re still that’s the only reason that’s keeping them. It’s not the money.” – Joe Rogan, admiring the ambition and drive of individuals like Elon Musk and Mark Zuckerberg.