JRE #1147 - Dr. Debra Soh

26-Jul-18

Joe Rogan Podcast: #1147 – Dr. Debra Soh

This podcast features Dr. Debra Soh, a former sex researcher, neuroscientist, columnist, and podcast host. It dives into a range of provocative topics, exploring the clash between science and social narratives, particularly in the realms of gender, sexuality, and identity politics.

1. The Selective Embrace of Science:

Dr. Soh argues that people often selectively embrace science, supporting it when it aligns with their pre-existing beliefs and rejecting it when it contradicts them.
She cites the example of climate change, where many readily accept scientific consensus but then dismiss scientific findings on gender and biological sex differences.
This selective approach highlights the potential for ideological bias to influence how we engage with scientific evidence.
The podcast underscores the importance of critical thinking and a willingness to confront uncomfortable truths, even when they challenge our cherished beliefs.

2. The Gender Fluidity Debate:

Dr. Soh critiques the notion of gender fluidity, questioning the validity of claiming more than two genders and arguing that this concept often stems from political correctness and a rejection of biological sex differences.
She points out that we readily acknowledge sex differences in other organisms, yet we resist doing so in humans, potentially leading to harmful consequences for individuals and society.
The podcast delves into the idea that biological sex is not merely a social construct, highlighting the scientific evidence for biological differences in the brain and body.
Dr. Soh raises concerns about the impact of this debate on children, arguing that transitioning children before they fully understand their own identities can be detrimental.

3. Rapid Onset Gender Dysphoria:

The podcast explores the phenomenon of rapid onset gender dysphoria, a recent trend where adolescent girls, often with no prior signs of gender dysphoria, suddenly identify as transgender.
Dr. Soh attributes this to social contagion and the potential for seeking acceptance and attention through identifying as transgender.
She emphasizes the importance of addressing underlying mental health issues, rather than solely affirming a transgender identity, particularly in children.
The podcast highlights the controversy surrounding this topic and the challenges faced by parents and mental health professionals who question the prevailing narratives.

4. The Role of Feminism:

Dr. Soh discusses the evolution of feminism, suggesting that some branches have strayed from their original focus on equality, embracing a more radical, anti-male stance.
She raises concerns about misandry, the hatred of men, and the negative consequences of such sentiments for both men and women.
The podcast explores the complexities of feminist discourse, highlighting the potential for generalizations and the silencing of dissenting voices within the movement.
Dr. Soh emphasizes the importance of pursuing genuine equality rather than resorting to hatred and division.

5. The Politics of Identity:

Dr. Soh delves into the phenomenon of identity politics, exploring how individuals often identify with certain groups and align their beliefs accordingly.
She highlights the potential for tribalism and the suppression of critical thinking when ideas become linked to specific groups.
The podcast discusses the challenges of maintaining a balanced perspective and the tendency for people to become entrenched in their ideologies, dismissing evidence that contradicts their beliefs.
Dr. Soh emphasizes the need for open discourse and a willingness to challenge our own assumptions, even when it means confronting the beliefs of those we consider allies.

6. The Google Memo Controversy:

The podcast revisits the controversy surrounding James Damore, a Google employee who was fired for writing a memo that questioned the prevailing narratives about gender and diversity.
Dr. Soh argues that Damore’s memo was based on scientific evidence, but that the media and Google leadership intentionally smeared him, dismissing his arguments and framing him as a misogynist.
She emphasizes the importance of allowing scientific debate and challenging established narratives, even when they are politically sensitive.
The podcast highlights the dangers of silencing dissent and the chilling effect it can have on free speech and intellectual inquiry.

7. Discrimination Against Asians:

Dr. Soh discusses the lawsuit against Harvard University, alleging discriminatory practices against Asian applicants, requiring them to achieve higher scores than other ethnicities to be admitted.
She argues that this constitutes racism and that the university’s efforts to promote diversity are hypocritical, punishing Asians for their academic success.
The podcast explores the broader issue of affirmative action, questioning its effectiveness and raising concerns about the unintended consequences of promoting equality of outcome over equality of opportunity.
Dr. Soh emphasizes the importance of addressing systemic inequalities, but cautions against using race-based quotas as the solution.

8. The Rise of Asian Technology:

The podcast examines the case of Huawei, a Chinese tech company that has faced significant barriers to entry in the US market, allegedly due to concerns about government espionage and intellectual property theft.
Dr. Soh suggests that another factor driving this resistance could be a fear of Asian technological dominance and the threat it poses to American companies.
She highlights the tension between economic competition and geopolitical concerns, questioning the US government’s rationale for blocking Huawei phones.
The podcast underscores the potential for bias and prejudice to influence economic and political decisions, even when cloaked in the guise of national security.

9. The Complexity of Human Interaction:

Dr. Soh discusses the challenges of navigating human relationships and the difficulty of determining the truth in situations involving conflict and differing perspectives.
She highlights the subjectivity of memory, the potential for distorted perceptions of reality, and the influence of emotions on how we interpret events.
The podcast explores the risks of relying solely on eyewitness testimony and the need for critical thinking and careful analysis when evaluating allegations of wrongdoing.
Dr. Soh emphasizes the importance of considering individual circumstances and the limitations of generalizations when navigating complex interpersonal dynamics.

10. The #MeToo Movement:

Dr. Soh acknowledges the prevalence of sexual harassment and assault in the workplace, but raises concerns about the potential for overreach and the dangers of assuming guilt based solely on accusations.
She challenges the “believe all women” mantra, arguing that it can lead to injustice for men who are falsely accused and that all accusations should be investigated fairly.
The podcast explores the complexities of sexual harassment, emphasizing the importance of context, power dynamics, and the subjectivity of experience.
Dr. Soh advocates for a system of justice that protects both victims and the wrongly accused, promoting due process and ensuring that all accusations are treated with sensitivity and care.

11. The Casting Couch:

The podcast addresses the well-known phenomenon of the casting couch, where sexual favors are exchanged for career advancement, particularly in the entertainment industry.
Dr. Soh acknowledges the power dynamics that exist between those in positions of authority and those who seek opportunities, recognizing the inherent vulnerability of individuals seeking to break into industries where success depends on networking and connections.
She highlights the complexities of consent and coercion in such situations, recognizing that transactional relationships can be both exploitative and consensual.
The podcast underscores the need for greater transparency and accountability in the entertainment industry, ensuring that individuals are not exploited in the pursuit of their dreams.

12. Open Relationships:

Dr. Soh discusses the increasing prevalence of open relationships, exploring the motivations behind this choice and the cultural shift in attitudes towards non-monogamy.
She emphasizes the importance of consent and mutual understanding in such relationships, acknowledging that they can work for some individuals but not for others.
The podcast highlights the diversity of human relationships and the need for greater tolerance and acceptance of alternative lifestyles.
Dr. Soh advocates for a more sex-positive society, where individuals are free to explore their sexuality without fear of judgment or shame.

13. The Cuckold Phenomenon:

The podcast explores the phenomenon of “cuckolding,” a sexual interest in witnessing one’s partner engage in sexual activity with another person.
Dr. Soh examines the psychology behind this interest, suggesting that it can be rooted in a desire for power, submission, or a fascination with taboo behaviors.
She highlights the complexities of sexual desire and the diverse ways in which individuals express their sexuality.
The podcast underscores the importance of respecting individual choices and preferences, even when they defy societal norms.

14. Male Feminism:

Dr. Soh discusses the phenomenon of “male feminists,” exploring the motivations behind men who champion women’s rights and questioning the sincerity of their intentions.
She suggests that some male feminists may be seeking to gain approval from women or compensate for their own insecurities.
The podcast highlights the potential for manipulation and exploitation within the context of male feminism, emphasizing the importance of discerning genuine allies from those who may be seeking personal gain.
Dr. Soh advocates for a more nuanced understanding of gender dynamics, recognizing that true equality should not be based on performative gestures or attempts to gain favor.

15. The Power of Social Media:

The podcast explores the role of social media in shaping public discourse and fostering both positive and negative trends.
Dr. Soh highlights the tendency for social media to amplify outrage and encourage mob mentality, where individuals feel empowered to attack those who hold dissenting views.
She discusses the challenges of navigating online communities and the potential for encountering negativity and misinformation.
The podcast underscores the importance of critical thinking and a healthy skepticism when engaging with information on social media.

16. The Limits of Academia:

Dr. Soh discusses her transition from academia to journalism and podcasting, highlighting the limitations she encountered in the academic world due to the prevailing political climate and the fear of repercussions for expressing dissenting views.
She argues that the pressure to conform to established narratives and the fear of censorship have stifled scientific inquiry and impeded the pursuit of truth.
The podcast explores the challenges facing academics who wish to explore controversial topics and the need for greater intellectual freedom within academia.
Dr. Soh emphasizes the importance of alternative platforms, such as podcasting and online journalism, that allow for greater freedom of expression and a wider range of perspectives.

17. The Censorship Debate:

The podcast examines the growing trend of censorship on online platforms, particularly YouTube, where content deemed offensive or harmful can be demonetized or removed.
Dr. Soh questions the effectiveness of such censorship, arguing that it can stifle debate, silence dissenting voices, and create a chilling effect on free speech.
She highlights the potential for bias and ideological bias to influence censorship decisions, suggesting that platforms may be suppressing content that challenges their own values.
The podcast underscores the need for open dialogue and a commitment to free speech, even when it involves uncomfortable or offensive views.

18. The Importance of Conversation:

Dr. Soh emphasizes the importance of having long-form conversations, arguing that they provide a more nuanced and insightful platform for exploring complex topics.
She critiques the superficiality of traditional media formats, such as short-form interviews and panel discussions, which often focus on talking points and scoring points rather than fostering genuine understanding.
The podcast celebrates the power of long-form dialogue, recognizing its ability to uncover complexities, challenge assumptions, and facilitate genuine intellectual exchange.
Dr. Soh advocates for a more thoughtful and nuanced approach to public discourse, encouraging deeper engagement with ideas and a willingness to listen and learn from different perspectives.

19. The Power of Vulnerability:

Dr. Soh discusses the importance of vulnerability in building meaningful connections and fostering genuine understanding.
She suggests that social media and traditional media often encourage people to present themselves in a curated and idealized light, limiting authentic interactions and hindering true connection.
The podcast celebrates the power of sharing personal experiences, acknowledging imperfections, and embracing the complexities of human nature.
Dr. Soh advocates for a more honest and open approach to communication, recognizing that vulnerability can foster empathy, build trust, and create meaningful connections.

20. The Future of Identity:

Dr. Soh explores the evolving nature of identity, reflecting on the potential for technological advancements, such as CRISPR, to reshape our understanding of gender and sexuality.
She speculates on the potential for future generations to experience a more fluid and inclusive approach to gender and sexuality, where individuals have greater control over their own identities and bodies.
The podcast contemplates the ethical implications of such advancements and the need for careful consideration of the potential consequences.
Dr. Soh emphasizes the importance of embracing diversity and accepting the complexities of human nature, while also promoting a sense of responsibility and ethical stewardship in the pursuit of scientific progress.

Memorable Quotes

“People selectively agree with science. Like, when it comes to climate change, everyone’s pro-science, but then when it comes to gender, they’re like, ‘Oh, no, that’s a social construct.'” – Dr. Debra Soh
“The whole gender thing is very strange right now. Like, there’s more than two genders, which is something people didn’t used to say.” – Dr. Debra Soh
“I’m glad I don’t have to be in school right now and deal with it, but to watch it from the outside, it’s just so interesting. Interesting in what way though? Well, because it’s almost like there’s a delusional aspect to it, like an agreed upon delusional aspect.” – Dr. Debra Soh
“I think that people who are younger, who are going through school now, are being taught this stuff. They actually don’t know the difference, and they actually believe it.” – Dr. Debra Soh
“I think there’s a fear of Asian success. I don’t think it’s bullshitting. I’ve been obsessed with this company, Huawei, recently. And I got obsessed with them for two reasons. One, because I read an article about the superiority of these cell phones that they’re producing that are not being accepted in America.” – Dr. Debra Soh

JRE #1147 – Dr. Debra Soh