JRE #164 – Shane Smith (Part 2)

This podcast dives deep into Shane Smith’s experience with the entertainment industry, exploring his journey from the rise of Vice Media to his recent lawsuit against the company. It delves into themes of artistic ownership, media manipulation, and the complexities of navigating a rapidly evolving industry.

1. Shane Smith’s Departure from Vice Media:

• Smith, a founding member and former CEO of Vice Media, went public with allegations of financial mistreatment and a lack of artistic control.
• He claimed the company was profiting from his work without proper compensation or recognition, a common grievance among creators.
• Smith’s lawsuit against Vice Media led to a financial settlement, marking a rare victory for an artist fighting for their rights.
• His experience highlights the ongoing power imbalances in the media industry and the struggle for creative autonomy.

2. The Impact of Social Media on the Entertainment Industry:

• Smith acknowledges the increasing accountability brought by social media, allowing artists to voice their grievances and connect with audiences directly.
• He argues that the internet has changed the landscape of the media business, shifting power from executives to creators.
• Social media platforms like Twitter and Instagram provide a platform for direct communication and transparency, challenging traditional media narratives.
• The rise of streaming services like Netflix has also disrupted the industry, offering artists greater control over their content and distribution.

3. The Legacy of Gandhi and the Debunking of Historical Figures:

• The podcast explores the controversial book, “Gandhi: Naked Ambition,” which presents a critical perspective on Gandhi’s life and legacy, alleging questionable sexual practices.
• This discussion touches on the broader theme of historical revisionism and the tendency to scrutinize and debunk even iconic figures.
• Smith’s perspective highlights the complexities of grappling with the flaws of historical heroes while acknowledging their significant contributions.
• The conversation raises questions about the role of nuance and context in understanding historical figures, especially in the age of social media and instant judgment.

4. The Challenges of Modern Culture and the Impact of COVID-19:

• Smith and Rogan discuss the pervasive sense of uncertainty and anxiety in modern society, exacerbated by the COVID-19 pandemic.
• They explore the erosion of trust in institutions, particularly government and media, due to inconsistent messaging and misinformation.
• The podcast delves into the psychological impact of the pandemic, highlighting the heightened sensitivity and emotional volatility that has become prevalent.
• They both acknowledge the need for greater understanding and empathy in an increasingly divided and polarized world.

5. The Power of Personal Experience and the Value of Exploration:

• Smith emphasizes the significance of firsthand experiences in shaping perspective and enriching one’s understanding of the world.
• He encourages intentional exploration and seeking out unique experiences as a means of personal growth and development.
• This theme relates to his decision to step away from Vice Media, seeking a more fulfilling and authentic path that aligns with his values.
• The podcast highlights the importance of embracing curiosity, seeking out new experiences, and challenging conventional wisdom.

6. The Evolution of Shane Smith’s Career Path:

• Smith’s career trajectory showcases a non-linear path, marked by unconventional choices and a willingness to embrace diverse opportunities.
• He navigated a series of distinct careers, from stand-up comedy to MMA commentary, ultimately finding success in unconventional fields.
• This journey highlights the importance of following one’s passions and trusting one’s instincts, even when they seem unorthodox.
• Smith’s diverse experience has shaped his unique perspective and informed his entrepreneurial ventures.

7. The Importance of Genuine Connections and Humility in Success:

• The podcast emphasizes the importance of treating everyone with respect, regardless of their position or social status.
• Smith highlights the importance of fostering genuine connections and building relationships with people from all walks of life.
• He emphasizes the value of humility and acknowledging the contributions of those who often go unnoticed.
• Smith’s personal approach to interacting with others reflects his values and underscores the power of kindness and empathy.

8. The Perils of Fame and the Quest for Meaningful Success:

• Smith and Rogan discuss the challenges of navigating fame and the often-destructive nature of celebrity culture.
• They acknowledge the pressures of constant scrutiny, the need for validation, and the temptation to prioritize external success over personal fulfillment.
• Smith’s decision to step away from Vice Media and focus on his passions reflects a desire for a more meaningful and authentic life beyond the trappings of fame.
• The podcast emphasizes the importance of finding purpose and meaning beyond external validation and material wealth.

9. The Culture of Online Outrage and the Importance of Critical Thinking:

• Smith and Rogan address the increasingly prevalent culture of online outrage and the tendency for social media to amplify negativity and divisive rhetoric.
• They explore the dangers of echo chambers and the tendency for people to seek out information that confirms their pre-existing biases.
• The podcast encourages critical thinking, questioning information sources, and fostering a more nuanced and balanced perspective on complex issues.
• They emphasize the importance of engaging with diverse viewpoints and fostering respectful dialogue, even when there are disagreements.

10. The Evolution of Stand-up Comedy and the Role of Social Media:

• Smith discusses the changing landscape of stand-up comedy, acknowledging the impact of social media and the rise of online comedy platforms.
• He reflects on the traditional process of honing one’s craft through live performances and the importance of developing a strong stage presence.
• Smith highlights the challenges and opportunities presented by social media, recognizing both its potential to democratize comedy and its potential for superficiality.
• He expresses a preference for the immediacy and authenticity of live performance while recognizing the innovative approaches emerging in the digital space.

11. The Power of Kindness and the Need for a Culture of Trust:

• The podcast underscores the importance of kindness and compassion in a world often characterized by division and distrust.
• Smith and Rogan emphasize the need for greater empathy and understanding in all our interactions, both online and offline.
• They argue that fostering a culture of trust and respect is essential for navigating the challenges of modern society.
• This theme highlights the interconnectedness of humanity and the importance of recognizing our shared humanity.

12. The Legacy of Stand-up Comedy and the Importance of Artistic Integrity:

• Smith reflects on the golden age of stand-up comedy, highlighting the significant contributions of iconic figures like Eddie Murphy and Chris Rock.
• He emphasizes the importance of artistic integrity and the need for comedians to stay true to their voices, even when facing criticism or pressure.
• Smith acknowledges the challenges of navigating a constantly evolving cultural landscape while maintaining authenticity and a strong personal vision.
• The podcast highlights the enduring power of stand-up comedy to challenge norms, provoke thought, and connect with audiences on a deeply personal level.

13. The Complexities of Drugs and Addiction:

• Smith and Rogan discuss the often-misunderstood nature of drugs and the impact of addiction on individuals and communities.
• They highlight the work of Dr. Carl Hart, a psychologist who challenges traditional narratives about drug use and explores the complexities of addiction.
• The podcast encourages a nuanced understanding of addiction, recognizing its biological, social, and psychological dimensions.
• They emphasize the importance of compassion, understanding, and evidence-based approaches to addressing addiction.

14. The Cultural Impact of Iconic Figures like Michael Jackson and Elvis Presley:

• Smith and Rogan reflect on the enduring cultural impact of Michael Jackson and Elvis Presley, acknowledging their pioneering status as superstars.
• They discuss the complexities of their legacies, navigating the admiration for their talent and the controversies surrounding their personal lives.
• The podcast underscores the impact of these figures on popular culture and their influence on generations of artists and fans.
• They acknowledge the challenges of reconciling the public persona with the private individual, particularly in the context of fame and media scrutiny.

15. The Evolution of UFC and the Rise of African Fighters:

• Smith and Rogan discuss the rise of African fighters in the UFC, highlighting the dominance of fighters like Francis Ngannou and the growth of the sport in Africa.
• They explore the remarkable stories of these fighters, often overcoming immense adversity and hardship to achieve success.
• The podcast highlights the global appeal of MMA and the sport’s ability to transcend cultural boundaries.
• They acknowledge the importance of recognizing talent and potential, regardless of one’s background or circumstances.

16. The Importance of Trust and Cohesion in Society:

• Smith and Rogan address the growing political polarization in the United States and the need for greater understanding and empathy.
• They emphasize the dangers of tribalism and the importance of fostering a sense of shared humanity.
• They advocate for a culture of kindness and respect, recognizing the importance of building bridges and fostering dialogue.
• The podcast highlights the interconnectedness of society and the need for greater cooperation to address common challenges.

17. The Role of Comedy in Healing and Understanding:

• Smith and Rogan celebrate the power of comedy to bring people together, offering a shared space for laughter and reflection.
• They acknowledge the ability of comedy to challenge norms, provoke thought, and provide a platform for open and honest dialogue.
• The podcast underscores the importance of using humor to navigate difficult times and to find moments of joy and connection.
• They recognize the potential of comedy to heal wounds, to foster empathy, and to bring people together.

18. The Significance of Finding Meaning and Purpose:

• Smith and Rogan discuss the importance of pursuing a life filled with meaning and purpose beyond external validation.
• They advocate for following one’s passions, embracing personal fulfillment, and seeking out genuine connections.
• Smith’s journey reflects a search for a more fulfilling life beyond the trappings of fame and fortune.
• The podcast encourages listeners to find their own paths to meaning and purpose, regardless of their circumstances.

19. The Impact of the Capitol Riots and the Fragility of Democracy:

• Smith and Rogan discuss the January 6th Capitol riots, highlighting the alarming attack on American democracy and the fragility of institutions.
• They explore the dangers of political extremism, the erosion of trust, and the need for greater civic engagement.
• The podcast emphasizes the importance of protecting democratic principles and ensuring the peaceful transfer of power.
• They acknowledge the need for greater accountability and for citizens to actively participate in the democratic process.

20. The Future of Entertainment and the Power of Innovation:

• Smith and Rogan discuss the future of entertainment, acknowledging the transformative power of technology and the evolving preferences of audiences.
• They highlight the importance of adapting to changing times, embracing innovation, and finding new ways to connect with audiences.
• The podcast explores the potential of new platforms and formats to shape the future of entertainment.
• They express optimism for the future, recognizing the ongoing creativity and resilience of artists and creators.

5 Memorable Quotes:

• “I don’t think I was ever, like, bitter. By this point of my life, I was… you would joke about it. You were angry about it, but not to the point where it fucked with your head, but you would joke about it.” – Shane Smith on his experience with Vice Media.
• “It wasn’t it wasn’t a a court of law. I don’t believe I would’ve got anything. Government? In a court of law, I think in a court of public opinion, it was a good time for me to… to say my peace.” – Shane Smith on his decision to go public with his grievances.
• “I think that coming up behind us, these kids are gonna in a whole new ballgame that we did. I hope so. I think there’s more accountability now because of the Internet, because of you know, people’s ability to express themselves is so much different than it used to be.” – Shane Smith on the changing landscape of the entertainment industry.
• “The reality is there’s less violence than ever before. There’s less murder than ever before. It’s a slow trend.” – Joe Rogan on the long-term trajectory of societal violence.
• “I just hope that if the economy can bounce back, people will start to relax again. And if not just vaccines, but also some form of effective therapy, so that even if someone’s not vaccinated and they get COVID, there’s a a very effective way to treat it if that does happen.” – Joe Rogan on his hopes for the future.